Boing creator, author and agent provocateur Cory Doctorow has posted a lengthy missive on Boing Boing pointing out all of the reasons he (and by extension, you) will not buy an iPad. Some of the reasons I agree with and some I don’t, but since this is a comic book blog I thought I would take Doctorow to task regarding his stance on the upcoming Marvel iPad app from Comixology.

One of Doctorow’s major points is that the Marvel app has locked down content so that a user cannot freely share comics with friends. This is of course true, but the problem is that I don’t see a sustainable model for digital comics that doesn’t impose SOME restrictions on user sharing – at least not until the notion of buying comics online has become as ubiquitous as, say, iTunes. Every digital distribution
method I’ve seen for comics thus far (and this includes several iPhone apps such as Comixology’s, Longbox and others) involves some measure of DRM. I don’t like it, but I can see the necessity of it until digital comics become the mainstream.

Doctorow also waxes nostalgic about the mom and pop comic book stores that have been the mainstay of many comic book geeks (myself included) over the years. Yet there are many details left out of this fond remembrance. Ever seen how much a direct market comics store marks up books just a week or two after they have been released? Ever seen a speculator clear the shelves of books before anyone else can get their hands on a single copy? Ever walked into a comics store to buy an issue, only to find out that you have to have a subscription with the store to get a copy of what you want? At my local store, the shelves are clear of most new issues by the time they arrive. The stores can’t afford to hang onto back stock, so there’s no room for issues that might attract a casual or even a new comics fan. These so-called mom and pop shops have been mistreating customers for decades. Is it any wonder, then, that more and more fans are looking to purchase digital comics – where prices aren’t arbitrary (and generally are lower than the skyrocketing prices of print comics) and where issues are available when they want them?

Like Cory Doctorow, I’ve been reading comics for a long, long time (going on close to 30 years now) and I’m more excited about the future of comics than the past. Maybe he likes musty, ramshackle stores with rude and often dismissive (if not strangely elitist) employees, but I don’t. I don’t have room for that kind of business in my life any more than I have room for dozens of comics-filled longboxes in my house.

Bring on the digital age!

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

Marvel Digital Comics Overview

I tried this yesterday, and I wanted to like it. I really did. I was even prepared to shell out the subscription fee. But, man, the Marvel Digital software is just plain broken. It slowed my netbook to a crawl (I’m assuming this is at least in part due to flash, but I could be wrong) and was just so clunky I could hardly bear it. Marvel can do much better. They’re just trying to see how little they can get by with and still generate a decent profit.

via The Weekly Crisis – Comic Book Review Blog by Christine Hanefalk on 2/17/10



With the launch of the iPad (see Kirk’s post on the subject), further fuel has been added to the ongoing discussion about digital comics. While I find the topic of various platforms and distribution models to be an interesting one, it remains somewhat theoretical for me and the many other people who live outside North America and don’t have the same purchasing options.

On the other hand, most of the talk about a large digital market for comics centers more on what it might one day become than what it is right now, and that seems to be true regardless of geography. For instance, Marvel Digital Comics Unlimited, Marvel’s most ambitious foray into digital comics to date, seems to be viewed by many as a sad product of backwards thinking, a sort of dead end transitional species in the evolution of the digital market place. I will agree that the kind of web-based platform that Marvel provides may not be the future, but I will say that it is a service that does fill a role in the here and now. For all its drawbacks, it offers a truly universal portal into the archives of some of the world’s most beloved comic books.

I’ve been a Marvel Digital subscriber for almost two years now, and am quite happy with how the platform has developed, both in terms of the interface and the increasingly wide selection of comics available. If you took a look at this service two years ago and decided that you’d rather wait for that as yet undefined moment in the future when the perfect digital platform would emerge, you may want to reconsider. Hit the jump to find out more.

What is Marvel Digital Comics Unlimited?


Marvel Digital Comics Unlimited was launched in November of 2007 as the latest, and most ambitious, in a line of various Marvel digital initiatives. The service is subscription-based and its extensive library currently offers over 5,000 comics. In order to access the comics in the database, the user has to be connected to the Internet as none of the content is available for download. While many readers would love to have the option of owning digital copies of their favorite comics, this kind of web platform means that there is no special application to download and that the content can be accessed from virtually any computer.

You can search the archive by series, character, creator and other criteria, and each comic is opened in a special Flash-based reader, complete with various controls. Images can be zoomed in, speech balloons can be magnified, and there are settings that allow you to view full the content by page, by spread or have it set to something called smart panels that does a lot of the work for you in terms of navigating the page.

The Good

There are a lot of things to like about Marvel’s digital service, and much of the early criticism is less valid today. The selection is huge and new comics are added relatively soon after print publication. You can even find entire mini-series these days without running up against the constant annoyance of being able to access only a few issues. While this isn’t true of all limited series, it no longer feels like Marvel is using the service only as a way to get people to buy the trades.

This brings me to the matter of the price. With the cost of comics going up, Marvel’s digital service actually offers good value for money. If you just want to try it out, there’s a monthly subscription for $9.99 that can be canceled at any time and an annual subscription for $59.88, which corresponds to just $4.99 per month. The monthly rate is a little steep, but the annual subscription is a pretty nice deal. Of course, if you just want to go for a test drive, there are freely available comics to choose from.

Before the latest version of the reader was introduced, there were pretty serious resolution problems, particularly with the older comics from the Marvel Masterworks collections. Zooming in or out would make the art look pixelated, and while it’s still not perfect, the situation has been much improved in recent months. For a look at what a scene viewed at three different zoom levels looks like, see the image below. These panels are from Neil Gaiman’s and Andy Kubert’s 1602 #4 (a series which is available in its entirety, by the way), and I recommend that you click the image below to view it to scale.

The Bad

As you can tell, I’m quite a big fan of Marvel Digital Comics Unlimited, but that doesn’t mean that there aren’t problems with it. Aside from the limiting factor of not being able to purchase the comics, the web interface, though improved, still looks like something out of a 1990’s video game. I suspect that alone is enough to put a lot of people off. Personally, I’m not thrilled about some of the controls either, and it seems like the user experience could be a whole lot smoother.

A bigger problem are the many bugs in the system. Occasionally, a comic will fail to load, the speech balloons might be misaligned against the background, and the text sometimes behaves strangely when zooming in and out. Most comics look perfectly fine, but there are enough times that something goes wrong for the general experience to be a little on the buggy side.

The search function isn’t perfect either, most likely due to many issues not being tagged correctly. You can search for a particular character and be rewarded with a search result that includes issues that doesn’t actually have that character in it. The search might also miss certain issues for the same reason. I’d also like to have the option to search for comics within the reader itself, and that’s not currently supported.

Who is it for?

People looking to catch up
If you’re looking to get into a book you’re not currently reading, and need background information that the latest trade simply won’t cover, you can find most of what you need here. Issues seem to be added a few months after they’ve been collected in trade, but aside from the most recent issues, a substantial portion of the comics published in the last ten years are in the system. To take one example, admittedly not at random, the entire second volume of Daredevil is available, from the first issue in 1998 to issue #116 which came out less than a year ago, and the same is true of many long-running series.

Fans of Silver Age
If you’re a fan of the old stuff and don’t feel like paying for the expensive Marvel Masterworks volumes in order to be able to enjoy older issues. As a general rule, the eras best covered are the last decade and the issues from the sixties and early seventies. Also, other popular runs of series which have been collected in print are available as well. If an issue has been collected and reprinted at any time, the odds are good that you’ll be able to find it.

The hesitant (or patient) trade waiter
For those who aren’t sure about picking up a particular trade and feel okay about waiting a few months, reading the first issue online when it appears in Marvel’s digital archives is a good way to sample it.

People with vision problems
No, I’m not joking. The ability to zoom in close, and selectively magnify word balloons does offer something that the paper version doesn’t in terms of accessibility.

Who may want to pass?

The hardcore collectors and big consumers
For those who buy a dozen or more comics a week and have been doing so for years, Marvel Digital Comics Unlimited has little to offer. Many people in this category probably either own everything they need to or might pass on the digital experience in favor of the “real deal” for other reasons.

The impatient
For those who like their comics hot off the press, the several months it takes for an issue to appear in the system clearly won’t cut it. While you’ll find many books printed in the last year, there is a delay even compared to when the trades come out. This is fine for the casual consumer of the genre, but hardly for those who like to discuss comics with their friends or online before the ink even has a chance to dry.

Fans of the 90’s
The collections in the Marvel Digital archives correspond mostly to issues which have already been collected in print. As mentioned before, this usually translates into the really old stuff, or most things from the last decade. Exceptions are the classic runs of certain books, but many readers who are fan of that particular character or creator might already own those collections in print. If you’re looking for an issue you suspect Marvel would rather pretend never saw print, you’re going to have to look elsewhere.

Conclusion

I’ve pretty much covered it all, so I’ll be brief here. Marvel Digital Comics Unlimited may not be the perfect platform for digital comics, but it’s here now and is a much better service in 2010 than it was in the early days. If you find yourself having to cut your pull list for financial reasons, there are other ways of getting your fix at a reasonable prize. True, the most recent issues are missing, but with thousands of others to choose from, you’re guaranteed to find something you haven’t read.

I’m a satisfied subscriber myself, and recommend that you give Marvel Digital a second chance if you’re at all interested in digging into the Marvel archives.

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

Paste Pot Pete Hits the Small Screen

There’s not much that surprises me, but I was taken aback that Paste Pot Pete is making a comeback via the Marvel Superhero Squad cartoon on the Cartoon Network.  Is there a toy version?  If so, I haven’t seen it.  Gotta have it.  Gotta.

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

Why We Need Digital Comics Now!

I bought comics as a small child, but just a few here and there, and only as much as a 1970s-era dollar bill would buy me (along with a little bit of candy to seal the deal).  It wasn't until around 1984 that I started collecting comics in earnest, an effort that would frequently drain my pittance of cash and whatever spare time I could afford for almost the next 20 years.  Something pretty drastic has happened over the last 26 years, and it's something that is draining the lifeblood from the comic book industry I once adored.

Take, for example the following cover:

Marvel_Super_Heroes_Secret_Wars_Vol_1_1.jpg

This was the first comic I bought on that fateful trip to the then-novel comic book shop across town.  Notice the cover price?  Just $0.75.  Need another example?  Ok, how about a copy of Amazing Spider-Man from roughly the same period?

300px-AmazingSpider-Man252.jpg

Even cheaper, huh? Just $0.60.  Now, let's take a look at a recent issue of Amazing Spider-Man for price comparison purposes:

Amazing_Spider-Man_Vol_1_545.jpg

Marvel's attempt at a joke only lands on decidedly nonplussed ears.  Only $3.99??!!!  This is a price increase of 565% over 26 years.  Has any other monthly publication gone through this drastic a price adjustment over the same number of years?

Certainly there are mitigating factors such as the increasing quality of comics as publications.  Except for black and white books, the public generally expects high-quality paper and sophisticated color separations, not to mention improved story and art.  There are also sophisticated economic forces at work as well as an aging readership with (presumably) more disposable income than a child to spend on such things as comics.  If you are interested in the economics of this price shift, I highly, highly recommend you read John Paul Konig's article, "The Amazing Spider-Man Battles the Inflation Monster."  Konig handles these issues with aplomb, far better than I could hope to here.

So, what's the point other than rubbing comics fans' faces into the pile of money they unload for their favorite books every month?  Simply this: comics are dying.  It's a slow death, but it's death all the same unless some drastic measures are taken by executives more visionary than those currently running the big two.  It's not the intellectual properties are dying. Far from it.  Marvel Studios is a huge success, and DC has made some deft moves recently in its revived Batman franchise.  Why aren't comic books moving like they used to?  For me, it all comes back to price.

If demand isn't there, even in a collectibles market (and let's face it, comics aren't really held for lasting value anymore, so their collectibility is theoretical at best), prices should come down.  But this hasn't happened.  Overall quality has improved, yes, but prices have continued to push ever higher.  

That's why it's time for the comic book publishing industry to FULLY embrace digital comics NOW – not at some unforeseen moment in the future.  The recording industry may not have liked the shift to a purely digital format, but they have made much more off of iTunes and other similar vendors than they might have if those options hadn't come along.  

There are certainly experiments with the format.  Comixology's Comics app for the iPhone is one, Graphic.ly is another and the long-awaited Longbox is a third option.
Of these, only Comixology's app has moved beyond the development phase, and it has also gotten Marvel onboard – though no recent issues, just past story runs.

What consumers want is simply a slicker form of what they can (unethically) get via torrent sites – new comics available the day they are published, for a reasonable fee.  The CEO of Longbox has gone on-record as saying the magic price point is $0.99, and I wholeheartedly agree.  

Give me an iTunes-like experience where I can buy my comics every Wednesday, and I'll be there week-in and week-out.  Right now I'm buying zero – ZERO – comics each week.  They're too expensive and too much clutter.  C'mon Marvel and DC – reel me back in. I'm dying to get hooked again.

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

The Iron Tater


Ok, so I guess by now everyone thinks the whole Mr. Potato Head-Movie Tie-in is overplayed, and maybe they're right. Still, you gotta hand it to them – the Iron Man 2 Potato Head is nicknamed "Tony Starch"?  Brilliant!

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

Twitter Trackin’

Conan_s Twitter Tracker strikes again, gets its own Twitter page _ Obsessable Technology News.jpg

I hate to be a part of an ever-growing, and ever-annoying trend, but yes – I blog, therefore I tweet. All is not lost, however, since many, many comics writers and artists have found their way onto the Twitter highway. Have I missed any? Drop me a line to let me know. Click any of the links below to follow any of these writers/artists:

Agent M (Ryan Penagos, Marvel.com editor/writer)

Andy Diggle

Bryan Lee O’Malley

Brian Michael Bendis

Brian Reed

Chris Eliopoulos

Ed Brubaker

Geoff Johns

Jimmy Palmiotti

Joe Hill

Joe Quesada

Kevin Smith

Mark Evanier

Mark Waid

Matt Fraction

Neil Gaiman

Rob Liefeld

Robert Kirkman

Todd Nauck

Tom Brevoort

Tom Peyer

Warren Ellis

Bagley Bigot


promo_jpeg.jpg

I’m a Mark Bagley snob. I admit it. I just don’t care for the man’s art unless it’s on one specific book – Ultimate Spider-Man. This is strange, considering I didn’t think much of his work when he pencilled Amazing Spider-Man in the early 90s. There is something that happened to his pencils when he teamed up with Brian Michael Bendis that helped them transcend their overwhelming mediocrity and sameness. I think it has much to do with the quality of Bendis’ scripts and the fact that the cast of characters is primarily made up of teenagers. Bagley is able to capture youth extremely well, so his teen versions of Peter Parker, Mary Jane Watson, etc, were exceptional. He has since moved on from Ultimate Spidey, and that’s a crying shame. As a result of his move, DC Comics has editorially decided that Bagley is the “it” penciller of the moment. I assume this is as a result of his recent work on Trinity, a series I gave up within the first ten issues. Trinity’s scripts were more problematic than the art (what has happened to Kurt Buseik???), but Bagley’s takes on DC’s big three left me distinctly underwhelmed.

Now, Mark Bagley has been handed one of DC’s flagship titles – the JLA. There’s a good side and a bad side to this move. The good side is that Bagley has been teamed with one of my favorite writers, James Robinson, so there’s the possibility that a new version of that old Bendis/Bagley chemistry can be ignited. The bad side is that I didn’t care for Bagley’s versions of Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman in Trinity, and I have no reason to believe they will significantly change for the JLA. I’ll give it a shot, at least to see what Robinson can do with the JLA. Maybe DC’s editors won’t handcuff his ideas like they did with Dwayne McDuffie.

Via www.toybender.com :

Fans of the Marvel Universe line (me) may look forward to seeing or most likely not seeing Wave 4 revision one at their local toy shoppe. Not only does it offer some of the more popular characters in the line that you may have missed before, but there’s some nice newer ones as well. May I direct you toward the awesomeness that is Moon Knight? Sweet chickens in heat, I’m going to need to get my hands on him. I’ve always been a fan of Moon Knight, but not really a dedicated reader of his comics until a few years ago. Even if you don’t like the character or what they’ve done with him, you’ve got to love that sweet ass costume.

marveluniversewave4rev1

Other figures I am on the look out for include black Spider-Man as well as the Hand Ninja, both of which I’ve passed on already. Seriously, the combination of not having steady income and these things being around eight dollars makes these purchasing decisions a lot harder. I know I’m a repeating parrot on this issue, but seriously eight dollars is too damned much for a three inch piece of plastic. I’m guessing that army building is a bit on the decline these days due to price and the economy. Anyway, I’m glad that I still have a little time before good old Captain America classic version is available.

[From Marvel Universe Wave 4 Revision 1 is Coming to Town]

Iron Man 2 is now shooting at Raleigh Studios (AKA Marvel Studios for all intents and purposes) in Manhattan Beach, CA.  As luck would have it, I got a chance to visit Tony Stark’s house (hizouse?) today and I gotta tell you, that is one impressive set.  I’d happily live there even with it parked on a soundstage wrapped in bluescreen.  There is that big hole blasted out of the ceiling that I’d want fixed first but other than that, I’m ready to move in.  Second unit was shooting so there wasn’t a lot to see but I got a chance to eyeball the Mark II armor in person and I got a glimpse of what appeared to be the Mark IV.  Judging from the pic above there must at least be a Mark IV in the new movie.  What do you think?

Why is Wolverine Popular?

Take a look at the various outfits Logan has worn through the years | Marvel.com News | Marvel.com.jpg

Friday’s premier of the X-Men Origins: Wolverine movie prompted critic Roger Ebert to write:

Am I being disrespectful to this material? You bet. It is Hugh Jackman’s misfortune that when they were handing out superheroes, he got Wolverine, who is for my money low on the charisma list. He never says anything witty, insightful or very intelligent; his utterances are limited to the vocalization of primitive forces: anger, hurt, vengeance, love, hate, determination. There isn’t a speck of ambiguity. That Wolverine has been voted the No. 1 comic hero of all time must be the result of a stuffed ballot box.

Pretty harsh (the review doesn’t get any more complimentary as it goes) but it raises a legitimate issue. Why IS Wolverine so popular? Long before the idea of film franchises lit the eyes of Avi Arad, Wolvie was supremely popular among comic book fans. The team of John Byrne and Chris Claremont made the character an icon, and the Wolverine mini-series featuring art by Frank Miller cemented the deal. That said, here are our top reasons why Logan/Patch/James Howlett/Wolverine has such lasting appeal:

  • The Beast with a Heart of Gold: And no – by “Beast” I don’t mean Hank McCoy. By now, everyone (and I do mean everyone) knows how Stan Lee transformed the comic book industry by creating characters who were more complicated than the standard 1960s fare. By the late 70s/early 80s, however, these once “fresh and complex” characters were becoming flat and lifeless once again, as the Marvel formula for superheroes became the de facto standard. Enter Chris Claremont and John Byrne, whose revitalized X-Men series ushered in a new age for comic book character development. If Lee added a second dimension to characters (rudimentary motivations for behaviors, guilt complexes, etc), Claremont and Byrne began adding a third. Their X-Men were friends first, teammates second, comic book superheroes third. By allowing characters to interact on a personal level, readers began to relate to these once iconic and godlike figures. Chief among these was Wolverine, whose tortured soul and misunderstood status appealed to the often-outcast comic book geek. Here was a sensitive character (who was physically short and often called “runt” by others) who could do more than just stand up for himself. Here was a more accessible Clark Kent for the masses. While less physically strong than Supes, he was nonetheless invulnerable/indestructible, and carried a six-pack of switchblades as well.
      Amazon.com_ Origin (Wolverine)_ Bill Jemas, Paul Jenkins, Joe Quesada, Andy Kubert.jpg
  • The Past Shrouded in Mystery: It’s no secret that comic book fans love a good mystery, and Wolverine’s unknown origin has proven to be a cash cow for Marvel again and again. Bits and pieces have trickled out over the past thirty years, and not all of them have been consistent with one another. Still, Marvel was able to keep interest high in this character’s background for decades before finally revealing all (or at least most) with the Jenkins/Kubert Origin mini-series. It remains to be seen, however, if interest will continue to remain as high now that so much is known about the character. Is Wolverine inherently compelling as a character, or only when his background is largely unknown?

  • The Super-Powers: Part Batman, Part Superman: The final part of the equation is that Wolverine is an intriguing amalgam of DC’s two iconic characters: Superman and Batman. The Superman connection has already been mentioned earlier in this article, but it bears mentioning again that comic book fans, notorious underdogs that they are (or were, depending on your view of the recent influx of comics-related culture into the mainstream), easily gravitate to characters who are physically impervious to harm. And, unlike Superman, Wolverine actually feels the pain of his injuries. He simply doesn’t die from them. As for Batman…well, no, Logan isn’t a normal fellow like Bruce Wayne (though “normal” is a relative term – how many multi-billionaires with murdered parents do you know?), but his brooding nature, coupled with his troubled past, gives him a strong connection to Bats. And while Wolverine doesn’t have a utility belt, don’t those adamantium-laced claws and bones count as gadgets of a sort? Is it any wonder, then, that a character with many of the appealing traits of two of the most enduring comic book characters should also garner popularity?

I agree with Mr. Ebert on a number of his points, as there are certainly weaknesses in Wolverine’s appeal, and hopefully I’ll be able to address those in the future. At this point it remains to be seen if the film will be as successful as initially hoped. Do comic book and movie fans of the character and franchise really want all of these mysteries revealed after all?