Iron Man’s Briefcase Armor

skinnerbox: If you haven’t seen it yet, track down the newest Iron Man 2 trailer. If that doesn’t get you jazzed up for the movie, nothing will. Oh – and I want some briefcase armor. Definitely!

via Project : Rooftop by Dean Trippe on 3/8/10


Note: How It’s Done is a new feature at Project: Rooftop, where we spotlight spectacular examples of official superhero redesigns, in comics, film, tv, and videogames.  Today, I’m taking a look at Iron Man 2’s briefcase armor. For more Iron Man at P:R, check out our Iron Man: Invincible Upgrade contest winners. – Dean Trippe, Editor

A new (and mind-blowingly rad) trailer for Iron Man 2 hit the webwaves last night, sparking a wildfire of “OH MY GOD“s on my Twitter feed. One of the many things I loved about 2008’s Iron Man film was the attention to story-driven detail regarding the lead hero’s various uniforms. This new trailer shows that returning director Jon Favreau and his team have maintained that focus in the sequel, with great looks for War Machine (good call on the red eyes), Black Widow (sporting a S.H.I.E.L.D. patch I must own), and other familiar Marvel characters. Iron Man is a perfect candidate for this sort of exploration, of course, as his true superpower (brilliance) is most noticeably evident in his beyond-next-gen armor designs.

In the comics and cartoons, Iron Man’s armor has frequently been shown to be collapsible, stored in a handy briefcase Tony Stark can carry when he’s not superheroing. On the one hand, this is fairly ridiculous, but on the other, some would say, better hand, it’s totally flipping awesome. The thing that made me and my Twittermates really freak out last night was the final scene in the new trailer, when Tony breaks out an emergency Iron Man suit, kept nearby in convenient briefcase form.

Having the briefcase itself form into a temporary suit of armor is a great update of the concept, and shows how good superhero redesign requires a combination of story-based conceptual thinking as well as updated aesthetic motifs. This netbook edition of the Iron Man is still functional and familiar, just lighter and more portable.  The use of red and silver as the color scheme rather than the default red and gold, recalls the “Silver Centurion” Iron Man armor of the ’80s, a value-added consideration for fans of the mythology. Say it with me now…

OH MY GOD. And that’s how it’s done.

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

The question is answered – this Toy Story 3 character is brand-spankin’ new, but as Freakengine suggested, it’s inspired by the Masters of the Universe line of toys. Ever feel like you’ve had a fake memory implanted in your brain? I think I need to see a doctor. :)


Is this Buzz-Off’s cousin?   This week the gang over at Disney/Pixar Toy Story 3 are revealing 14 new characters that we will be meeting in the upcoming film over at their official Facebook page. This newest reveal really caught my eye: Meet Twitch, the insectaloid warrior, where MAN + INSECT = AWESOME! This sturdy action figure stands [...]

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

I’ve become strangely fascinated with Project: Rooftop, a blog dedicated to posting artists’ redesigns of classic Marvel/DC characters. It’s a clever idea that’s also well-executed, and it would be really interesting to see some of these designs make their way to the Big 2 one of these days.

via Project : Rooftop by Dean Trippe on 3/4/10


Note: Career Day is a new feature here at Project: Rooftop. Contributor Calamity Jon Morris and I wanted to open up the site’s focus a bit to allow for more radical (read: non-continuity) redesigns based on genres and professions, as we’ve actually run a few very good ones (like Maris Wicks’ Park Ranger Wolverine) in the past. If you’d like to submit a Career Day redesign, just check our Guidelines for submissions info. - Dean Trippe, Editor

Joel Carroll

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

The Goon Movie Is In Good Shape

Skinnerbox: Any news about The Goon movie is good news – particularly when it is apparently still on track…

via Splash Page by Rick Marshall on 3/1/10


The GoonIt’s been a while since we received any news regarding “The Goon,” the animated feature based on Eric Powell’s award-winning comic book series. When we caught up with the creator last month to discuss his upcoming return to the “Goon” comic and “Buzzard” spin-off series, we made sure to get an update.

According to Powell, the first draft of the “Goon” script is finished and receiving some necessary tweaks, animators Blur Studios are working on some test footage, and he hopes to see producer David Fincher (“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”) pushing the project forward in the near future.

“I think as soon as Fincher is finished working on the film he’s on now, they’re going to try and get this thing up and going,” said Powell. “It’s in good shape. We’re slowly grinding forward, but all the blocks have to be in place first.”

“I fell into a perfect situation with guys who really get the comic,” he added. “You have to change things to make it fit in a format like this — especially with ‘The Goon,’ because the comics were such self-contained stories and so episodic. You can’t do it like ‘Sin City’ and do a linear telling of the comic.”

As for any changes that come about as part of the adaptation process, Powell reiterated that fans shouldn’t be too worried — after all, he’s the one writing the script.

“We had to adapt it for the film, but I wrote the script — so The Goon doesn’t fall from the sky in a meteor or have superpowers or anything like that,” he laughed. “It is The Goon and it has the feel of the The Goon. The story had to change a little to get it to work in a film format, but the characters, the world, and the interaction between the characters are all the same.”

After an appetite-whetting teaser wowed fans during last year’s Comic-Con in San Diego, Powell told MTV News he can’t wait to show off more of the film. However, the team wants to get the project set up at a studio proper before revealing too much.

“I can’t wait for people to see more of this stuff, because the stuff I’ve seen just blows my mind,” he said. “They’re holding off on all that stuff, but as soon as we get a studio announced, I’m sure Blur is eager to show off all the good work they’re doing.”

“Once that stuff is in place, there’s going to be a flood of new material coming out of there,” he promised.

As for the other big question surrounding the project, Powell said Fincher is likely to take an active role in the film even if he doesn’t direct “The Goon.”

“Directing an animated film is a little different form directing a live-action film, but they’re still making those decisions,” he explained. “Fincher is heavily involved and he’s going to have final say over everything, so we will get his input — he won’t just be a figurehead.”

What do you think about the “Goon” news thus far? Let us know in the comment section or on Twitter!

Related Posts:
Paul Giamatti Hopes ‘The Goon’ Movie Moves Forward, Met With David Fincher For Comic-Con Teaser
FIRST LOOK: ‘The Goon’ Creator Eric Powell’s New ‘Buzzard’ Miniseries!
EXCLUSIVE: Eric Powell On ‘The Goon’ Heading To iPhones… And Back To Print!

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

10 Favourite Daredevil Covers

Skinnerbox: I’m not sure I agree with all of these (have to think about that one for a while), but there are some stellar ones listed below. I’m most intrigued by the Black Widow cover as it foreshadows Miller’s move to the stark black/white of his much later Sin City work.

via The Weekly Crisis – Comic Book Review Blog by Ryan K Lindsay on 3/2/10


Daredevil has had a lot of good writers over his nearly fifty year history, and this fact is always spotlighted as people say that each writer makes a personal run while on DD because that’s the platform that can incorporate it. Many forget to mention that he’s also had some absolutely phenomenal cover artists over time as well. To pick a top ten out of what would amount to nearly six hundred images wasn’t easy. But I did it.


Here are the ten DD images that have most grabbed me over my many hours spent reading the title.

Top 10 Tuesdays - 10 Favourite Daredevil Covers

10 – Daredevil #188 – ‘The Widow’s Bite
Cover by Frank Miller

There’s something about this cover that simply sings out unlike any other. The colour scheme should be muted for all the black, but instead the intricate white lines of the web make me think of a broken windshield.

It is a bold statement, the defeated form of Daredevil slung into the middle is a different way to project our hero into the viewer’s eye, and the brutal hold in which the Black Widow has him is menacing, personal, slightly scary, and downright effective. I’m not sure if she’s going to help him or eat him. And either way looks like it will make a cool story to me.

When scanning through the back catalogue this one always catches my eye and makes me stop. If only Natasha had better hair though, this cover would be up a few places if she had the long hair.

9 – Daredevil #323 – ‘Conflict’
Cover by Scott McDaniel

Long before New Avengers was teasing something that wasn’t actually going to happen, Daredevil gave us a symbiote clad Matt Murdock.

The story actually features a guest appearance by Eddie Brock with his living black suit. At no point does the suit jump ship from its host and attach to Matt Murdock, but it certainly would be interesting if it did. The radar sense plus a watered down Spider-Sense means no one would ever get Murdock on the first day of April ever again.

While from a lackluster run that has been forgotten, mostly, in the canon of Daredevil, you have to at least respect this cover, it’s one opportunity where they gave it all they had. It’s a good thing that they didn’t showcase the DD suit he had at the time, it was neither yellow nor red, but I am sad that they didn’t use the reveal which is at the end of the issue; bad ass rogue S.H.I.E.L.D. cyborg, John Garrett.

8 – Daredevil #169 – ‘Devils’
Cover by Frank Miller

Bullseye has always been a bit of a mad character and we can see this very early in his career. Here Bullseye is seeing everyone as his arch-nemesis, Daredevil, and if the cover implication is correct, he’s started killing them all.

I love that at first glance it just looks like he’s surrounded by defeated bodies but upon a closer look you see that each unsuspecting person has been placed into the DD red gear. It’s a scary thought that such a skillful villain could lose it and take out everyone around him.

The greatest element of the cover though is Bullseye himself, hogging the round spotlight. His face shows such maniacal glee that you know is going to snap very soon when he can’t kill the last DD as more keep coming. He looks happy, and the scary clown always does, but the sad emptiness behind it all is what really controls the vehicle into the crash.

7 – Daredevil Vol 2 #57 – ‘The King Of Hell’s Kitchen (Part 2)
Cover by Alex Maleev

It’s nice to see Matt Murdock get a cover as his red tights wearing alter-ego always seems to steal the lime light.

There’s a masterful composition about this cover that really draws my eye along the vertical and horizontal lines. The writing going up and down, the raised sword both parallel and adjacent to the letters being formed.

Excellent use of white space as a frame that finally draw my attention to Murdock’s face. He’s glancing on a downward angle, he’s waiting and about to mean some serious business. It’s a showdown and we don’t need to know whom it is against, we just need to know that Murdock is prepared for it.

The entire cover makes me think I’m seeing the calm, the very Zen centre, of what will be a ninja fuelled storm.

6 – Daredevil #175 – ‘Gauntlet’
Cover by Frank Miller

Daredevil and Elektra stand shoulder to shoulder against a shared foe. They are united and we should be happy but instead we get blood on the wall asking us if this could possibly be ‘The End?’

Knowing the way DD had been published up to this date, I would not have been surprised to find that DD ended with a bang, not a whimper. He’d get a soldier’s finale and have his ass kicking girl by his side as they were pushed up against the wall.

I also like the ninja swords forming half a frame and pointing all eyes to our eponymous hero and his ex/assassin/lover. This question raises so many questions, literally, and figuratively, and I’m drawn in instantly. It’s one scene, again a calm within a fight, where breath is drawn and sides are taken and the fight is about to get real. It’s the perfect snap shot moment.

5 – Daredevil Vol 2 #46 – ‘Hardcore Part 1’
Cover by Alex Maleev

This is a pin up, when you take it for what it is, but it doesn’t feel like a pin up. It feels like we’re seeing one frame of a scene through Murdock’s eyes. One of his many old flames (and haven’t there been so many that could grace a cover), Typhoid Mary, is standing in front of him and she’s about to do something nasty.

How do I know this? Because she’s always about to do something nasty and she really only knows how to do nasty things, and that seems obvious by the trashy stance she rocks out.

I look at this cover and I put myself in Murdock’s shoes and I worry about what is to come. It is also interesting to note that Maleev originally had a slice of Mary’s nipple, with a ring, showing but had to take it out. A smart choice, and a great Easter egg, of sorts, but in the end just the way Maleev presents Mary is such a bold statement. It’s one thing to have this character in JRJr’s pencil but quite another to have her portrayed so realistically. Makes you wonder just how dirty Murdock really is when you know his history with her.

4 – Daredevil #121 – ‘Foggy Nelson: Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D.’
Cover by Gil Kane

There’s enough text on this cover to fill an issue, and you get enough to chew on for a few minutes if you really take it in. I’m always a sucker for HYDRA so seeing their logo in the background is a pleasure, not to mention DD in some sort of Dreadnought fight club scenario.

Murdock feels like destroying something beautiful. The fact that the cover uses an asterix to explain what a Dreadnought is may just be pure and sublime genius.

Finally we get the tease that Foggy Nelson might just be an agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. I really hope he’s not just pushing Nick Fury’s papers around like he does for Murdock. As far as old school DD covers go, this one takes the cake for me. And it’s on fire, won’t somebody please think of the fire safety concerns?

3 – Daredevil: Father #5 – ‘Heeeeeeere’s Johnny!’
Cover by Joe Quesada

This cover works because of its simplicity. It’s just a head shot, but there’s more and the little details make this so much more than just a mug shot.

Quesada’s use of black space on the character give a very foreboding sense of muscle and danger. Quesada’s Daredevil for Father was a brutal hulk. He was the son of a boxer and so had the build for it. It was an experimental style and one that I know I liked quite a bit.

The darkness of DD’s eyes here make me think that he’s switching off the human part of himself and is about to dish out a bit of the old ultra-violence, and if that smirk is any indication then he’s going to enjoy it while he can.

The final touch on the cover is the soupçon of blood coming out of the mask and down across his lips. Someone has had their turn and they haven’t done enough, now it’s Murdock’s chance for a reply.

2What If? #28 – ‘What if Daredevil Became An Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D.’
Cover by Frank Miller

A What If? cover can get a jump on the rest because it can posit any situation it likes. In this instance it’s compiled all of my greatest hits of the Marvel U; Daredevil, S.H.I.E.L.D. and HYDRA. All they needed to throw in was Danny Rand as his sidekick and I’d officially be in story heaven.

Everyone likes to see those HYDRA goons get what they’ve got coming but no one ever expects those blows to come from Matt Murdock in one of those spiffy S.H.I.E.L.D. suits. The straps on the thighs, the under-the-shoulder harnesses, they’ve got it all. Then you get the red hair and the black band across the eyes and it’s all over. Check. Mate. HYDRA.

1 – Daredevil Vol 2 #105 – ‘Without Fear Part 6’
Cover by  Marko Djurdjević

This is hands down, flat out, my favourite comic cover of all time. I’m not saying it’s the perfect cover, but it surely has to be close.  

Djurdjević is a master of the painted cover that looks like it’s almost a sculpture. He gives a depth and smell that makes me think that Frank Frazetta had a steampunk baby 31 years ago.

Mr Fear finally looks fearful. He looks like he’s someone to be reckoned with and he’s gotten the right reaction from Daredevil. The hero is angry, he’s charging, and Mr Fear just stares him down. No fear in the mask, no hesitation at all in that steel visage in the slightest. All life is gone, there is only the hatred and the vengeance.

Brubaker’s Without Fear arc was my favourite of his run and this cover was the greatest way to end that story. Mr Fear giving the cold stare and knowing that he’s already won. And if you’re not sure of Djurdjević’s mastery of the artistic form, if the metal reflection didn’t sell you on it then you need look no further than the material that robes our villain. That’s detail, kids, that’s a care for the art. And it makes everyone else care too, it promotes investment.

Conclusion

Those are my ten Daredevil covers. Tough choices but ones I stand by. There were some extremely excellent covers that nearly made the list but these are the final entrants. These are the ones I’ll always remember.

What about you?  What are you favourite Daredevil covers?  What makes the cut for you?  What do you think are the best, and why?


Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

I suppose I was one of the last human beings on the planet to see James Cameron’s Avatar (I think of that as its title, to be abbreviated JCA right alongside TESB and LOTR).  I saw it this afternoon in a good theatre in Burbank that was utilizing the Real D 3D system.  My reaction?  “So what?”  I honestly thought the 3D-ishness (what little there actually was) detracted from my own immersion in the story.

As soooo many posts before this one have declared, 3D cinema has come and gone several times over the years.  I won’t belabor the point by listing them again.  Yes, this new version is better than those and yes, Avatar was shot with 3D as part of its very essence.  Cameron designed a new binocular camera system that was designed to better mimic human vision.  While Cameron’s setup is indeed better and easier on the eyes (I could barely sit through the very short Shrek 3D attraction at Universal Studios) I still don’t see (pun intended) the point.  Here’s why:

1. When the visual focus is chosen for you by the camera operator the film presents a decidedly unrealistic way of seeing.  Isn’t 3D supposed to be all about realism?  Rack focusing happens often in Avatar and shallow focus is used even more frequently.  It’s like the filmmakers want to have their cake and eat it too.  They want to rely on the same tried and true visual shorthand they’ve had in their toolbox for years while at the same time embracing this new brand of 3D.  I say it would be better if 3D opened up an all-new film vocabulary.  Early dramatic filmmakers simply put plays on in front of a camera.  It was years before they figured out that they could do things other than what had been done on stage.  The same sort of thinking needs to happen with 3D.

2. Regardless of the attempts to keep things bright, Avatar looked awfully dim to me…especially after I took the glasses off and saw the bright image I should have been seeing in 2D.

3.  I wear glasses.  The Real D glasses sucked bones!  It was a very uncomfortable three hours.

4.  Image strobing ruined many of the more complex camera moves.  Shouldn’t new technologies make movies look better?

5.  I just didn’t see that much added depth in the images.

6.  The CGI glass glares that were added at mid-depth in many of the cockpit scenes made me think my nifty new 3D glasses were dirty.

As a special feature extra for this post, I’ll add these bonus gripes:

7.  Almost every design we see (and hear) is from another Cameron film.  The choppers look like a cross between the Aliens drop ship and the hunter killers in Terminator.  The neon nightime pallet and the floaty creature-seeds were curiously similar to the underwater aliens in The Abyss.  The corporate weasel reminded me of Carter Burke.  Need I go on?

8.  Sully looked different every single time he was on camera.  I’m sure Cameron has some justification for this but I cry foul at whatever he comes up with.  The problem is that actor Sam Worthington looks different in every movie he’s in.  He has at least four completely different looks here and they don’t proceed along in any sort of linear fashion.  It’s as if they had reshoots after the beard was gone and rather than have Worthington wear a chin wig they added a shaving scene.  I honestly think it would have been better to see Worthington proceed from the jarhead look he has at the beginning of the film to the pseudo-hippie John Lennon look at the end.  This is not a subtle film, folks.  It could have used this.

I know this all makes it sound as though I didn’t enjoy the movie.  I did.  I just think I would have enjoyed it more in 2D.  The 3D effects (and glasses) left me outside the dramatic action in a way few good movies do.

Midichlorians are the Devil!

Skinnerbox: The title says it all. Read the rant below.

via io9 by Charlie Jane Anders on 2/26/10


Lately, when people ask Lost’s producers if they’re going to answer our questions, they bring up Star Wars‘ midichlorians, as proof that some things are better not explained. But like so many people, they’re missing the real reason midichlorians sucked.

Damon Lindelof told E! Online a while back:

There are certain questions about the show that I’m very befuddled by like, ‘What is the Island?’ or ‘What do the numbers mean?’ We’re going to be explaining a little more about the numbers, maybe significantly more about the numbers, but what do you mean by ‘What do the numbers mean?’ What is a potential answer to that question? I feel like you have to be very careful about entering into Midi-Chlorian territory. I grew up on Star Wars; I’ve seen the Star Wars movies hundreds of times; I can recite them chapter and verse, and never once did anyone ever say to me or did it occur to me to say, ‘What is the Force, exactly? Can you explain that for me, better than Alec Guinness does?’ I understand, ‘When are we going to find out about Libby?’ That’s a very finite question. ‘Who is Jacob?’ OK, yes, we’ve been talking to this guy named Jacob, so those questions then should have answers, but ‘What is the Island?’ That starts to get into ‘What is the Force?’ It is a place. I can’t explain to you why it moves through space-time-it just does. You have to accept the fact that it does.

Carlton Cuse similarly told the Chicago Tribune’s Maureen Ryan:

I mean, mystery exists in life and we kind of always go back to the midi-chlorians example [in the 'Star Wars' prequel films]. Your understanding the Force was not aided by knowing that there were little particles swimming around in the bloodstreams of Jedi.

This is part of a wide-spread problem with midichlorians — I would say a galaxy-wide misconception, in fact. People understand that midichlorians were a terrible idea, but they don't understand why they were a terrible idea. And this misunderstanding allows storytellers to get away with saying they won't explain stuff which they really should explain.

(And for the record, I still have faith that Lost will answer the questions that really need to be answered — including why the heck this island is so important, and why the battle over the island's future isn't just a random real-estate dispute, no different than your uncles fighting over your grandma's Florida beach condo. This isn't especially a slam against Lost — just trying to clear up a disturbance in, you know, the Force. And stuff.)

So let’s break this down once and for all.

1. We already had an explanation for the Force.

Check out what Obi-Wan Kenobi says in the original Star Wars:

Well, the Force is what gives a Jedi his power. It’s an energy field created by all living things. It surrounds us and penetrates us. It binds the galaxy together…. A Jedi can feel the force flowing through him.

That’s actually a pretty clear-cut explanation, although it doesn’t go into particle physics or anything. But compared to a lot of science-fiction explanations, it’s refreshingly free of technobabble, and it’s fairly specific: The Force is an “energy field created by all living beings.” Possibly mystical and soul-related, as Han suggests, or possibly just some kind of life-energy. And certain people have an in-born ability to sense and interface with this life-energy.

What’s so hard to understand about that?

But midichlorians actually contradict this explanation. All of a sudden, instead of there being an energy field that “binds the galaxy together,” there are little microscopic life forms inside of the Jedi, allowing them to… do what? What do the microscopic entities have to do with the galaxy-wide life force? Are they like symbiotes that allow you to connect to the energy field? If the Force is in every living thing, then why do only some people have midichlorians? Does the Dark Side of the Force have different-flavored midichlorians than the light side?

What was a fairly clear-cut explanation suddenly becomes incredibly muddled.

It’s like the sort of thing that happens to superheroes all the time. Spider-Man used to have a clear-cut (if silly) explanation for his powers: he was bitten by a radioactive spider. But then, at some point, the writers of his comic decided there needed to be a “Spider totem” involved, and a spider queen, and Anansi knows what else. Flash suddenly had to have the “Speed Force” bolted on top of his previously simple origin, and Green Lantern had to have a whole emotional spectrum, with different colored rings for different emotions. And so on. It’s part of the nature of retcons: What was once simple becomes baroque.

Instead of building on the explanation we already had, Phantom Menace demolished it to put up an ugly new monstrosity.

2. If someone had told you Episode I explains more about the Force and how it works, you’d have been stoked.

Seriously. Imagine if, back in 1998, someone had told you the new movie includes the Jedi finding young Anakin and discovering his huge potential Force powers — including the means by which they determine that the Force is moving strongly in this one. You'd have thought, "Ooh, Lucas is going to open up the mysteries of the Jedi. There'll be cool Yoda-esque koans and riddles and spiritual disciplines, and possibly more blindfolds."

And you'd have been right — in theory, more understanding of the Force would have been a good thing. It's one of the coolest things about Star Wars. If you wanted to go back in time and take all of the discussion of the Force out of Empire Strikes Back, I would have to go back in time and stop you, because that stuff all rules. So yeah, more of that type of exploration of the Force would have been terrific.

It's not that midichlorians were an explanation for something which should have been mysterious — it's more that they were a dumb, ridiculous technobabble concoction. And they're not an explanation you can build on, which is even worse. You can build a whole architecture on top of "an energy field that connects all living beings," and the original trilogy did, quite well. But you can't build on top of "microscopic critters in the blood."

It’s the difference between explanation (Empire Strikes Back) and hand-waving (Phantom Menace). What the Force is, and how it works, is something that we’re better off being shown, through examples like Yoda’s Taoist teachings. Telling us how the Force works, by tossing around silly jargon, isn't really an explanation — it's just Lucas flailing around with a glue-gun, sticking things together randomly.

So your take-away point here is that it's not that explanations are bad — ham-handed, idiotic explanations that make things less cool are bad.

3. Star Wars never made “What is the Force?” into a central mystery.

There’s a reason that Star Wars explains what the Force is the very first time we hear about its existence: It's part of the set-up. We're not supposed to sit around wondering what the Force is, except to the extent that we see Luke learning how to use it. Luke's lessons in the Force are our way in to understanding its subtleties — but the over-arching question of what the Force is? We know that from square one.

Likewise, we’re not really supposed to wonder how the Enterprise flies on Star Trek, or how the TARDIS dematerializes on Doctor Who, or how the ships can “jump” on Battlestar Galactica. Those things are not set up as huge mysteries that the characters are trying to get to the bottom of. We don’t get tossed clues about the nature of the Enterprise’s engines. The mystery of the Enterprise’s engines and how they work does not deepen over time. Scotty does not say “I’m doin’ the best I can, Cap’n, but I canna understand what these Dilithium crystals have to do with anti-matter in the first place!” Every now and then, these shows will throw fans a bone, by mentioning some new details of how these things work. But we’re not supposed to think of these things as central mysteries to be solved.

The Force is the same way.

Lost’s island, though, is mysterious from the moment our castaways crash on it, and its mysteries deepen in every episode. Even now, I constantly see promos for Lost reruns which show Charlie asking where the hell this place is. The show has gone out of its way to play up the mystery of what the island is, and who Jacob is, and how the Man In Black got there, and so on. It is the central mystery of the show, and one I still have great confidence will be resolved, in spite of Cuse and Lindelof’s statements trying to lower our expectations.

Why would Cuse and Lindelof be trying to lower our expectations anyway? Could it be because they saw another show with a cult following, which promised “all will be revealed,” over and over again, and then turned out to have a somewhat… idiosyncratic definition of the word “all”? But let’s not reopen old wounds.

The point is, there’s a difference between your set-up and your big mysteries. We don’t expect Lost to explain how the plane that crashed on the island was able to fly in the first place — Even though I don't fully comprehend all the principles of aerodynamics that go into keeping a jet plane in the air, I know they work because I've flown in them. I'm not even looking for a detailed explanation of, say, how the island is able to move through time and space. We've seen it work, so we know it works, and we've gotten enough details about unique magnetic forces to let us fill in the blanks.

But when you set up something as a central mystery and you make people start talking about it in grandiose terms (i.e., referring to the island as more important than, say, Tuvalu) then you owe us an explanation, all right. It doesn’t have to be a series of diagrams or schematics, or go into ridiculous detail. It shouldn’t contradict what we’ve already learned. And it would be nice if it had some element of showing along with the telling. But one way or another, if you make a big deal out of asking a question, then you have to provide an answer. That’s just basic storytelling.

So let’s stop using midichlorians as shorthand for “explaining stuff which should remain a mystery.” Midichlorians are more like “a clumsy retcon that screws up an explanation we already had.”

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter

Skinnerbox: Here’s a really clever way to promote a book. Like the writer below, however, I wish the filmmakers had spent some of their budget on better makeup for the villain – or maybe actually hire an actor with a mustache? Regardless, I’m jazzed about the book. How about you?


I’m not generally a fan of promotional trailers for comics and books — most rely on dull montages and even worse music — but this new spot for Seth Grahame-Smith’s upcoming novel Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter is incredibly well done. Well, if you can ignore the really obvious wig and fake mustache on whom I presume is vampire-John Wilkes-Booth.

The novel, Grahame-Smith’s follow-up to the bestselling Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, depicts Lincoln as the savior of the Union and lifelong enemy of the undead. The author has a couple of comic-book connections: He was among the genre novelists who contributed to the latest Marvel Zombies miniseries. In May, Del Rey/Villard will release a graphic-novel adaptation of Pride and Prejudice and Zombies.

Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter is due March 2 from Grand Central Publishing.

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

Skinnerbox: Sounds like a series I may have to check out – probably after I catch up on Pluto, 20th Century Boys and Oishinbo. For someone who isn’t very “into” manga, I’m sure reading a lot of it these days.

via Comics Worth Reading by Johanna on 2/22/10


When I first heard of The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service, it was well-recommended, but I wasn’t sure it was for me, given that it was classified as horror and the premise involved lovingly depicted dead bodies. I’m glad I went ahead and tried it, because I very much enjoyed it. It reminded me of Pushing Daisies, if that show was more laconic and Japanese.

The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service Book 1 cover
The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery
Service Book 1
Buy this book

Five students at a Buddhist university aim to bring justice to dead bodies with unfinished business using their unique abilities. Kuro (who most resembles a monk, with his bald head) can hear the voices of the dead when he touches their corpses. We later learn that he’s got a kind of scarred guardian spirit assisting him. Numata dowses for bodies the way others claim to use sticks to find water.

Makino is a whiz at embalming, which doesn’t make much sense in a country where most people are cremated. With her short stature, cute clothes, and pigtails, she also resembles a perky kid, which makes her glee at working on bodies even creepier. Yata is accompanied by an alien that has taken the form of a vaguely lizard-looking hand puppet. (He calls himself a “space sock” at one point.) Ao organizes the group with her planning and computer skills.

Another thing they all have in common is that they’re actively looking for some way to make money, not just use their training to run temples. They help souls that are still trapped in their bodies because of a desire for vengeance, most often, but sometimes for other reasons (resolution for a loved one of some kind, perhaps). Unfortunately, there isn’t always a way to get paid for fulfilling these last wishes; having corpses for customers can be a problem. In another culture, these tales might have been ghost stories, but the focus here is on the physical instead of the spiritual, thus the “delivery service” name, as they move the bodies to where they want to be. Sometimes, they even inspire the bodies to move themselves one last time.

In their first case, a man who hanged himself wanted to be with his dead girlfriend, an up-and-coming singer controlled by her father. The revelation of what was keeping them apart, and the way their story is resolved, is frankly disgusting, although emotionally plausible. It’s a good test case, both for the team of characters, and the reader. If you get through that, the rest of the book will be fine.

The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service Book 2 cover
The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery
Service Book 2
Buy this book

The second body allows Numata to show off what a sunglass-wearing badass he is, as he totes a cabinet full of old woman around on his back and punches through a windshield with his skull ring. The grandmother who passed is looking for an appropriate resting place, one with dignity. There’s also a jigsaw corpse, assembled from different bodies by a serial killing dissectionist, and in the weirdest story in the book — which is saying a lot — an insurance actuary uses his knowledge of the odds to put people in situations that increase their chance of death. It’s “murder by probability”, with plausible deniability on his part and eventually, poetic justice.

The thin-line art captures the bodies’ decay, reminding you that these are corpses, but without being grotesque for its own sake. The bodies are often more shadowed, more three-dimensional, than the living characters. The artist uses a wide palette of expressions, although at times the faces are a bit off. Still, I’d rather see the stretch to provide variety instead of sticking to a more limited, more perfect gallery. Also note that the material can be explicit, since bodies don’t always wear clothes (especially the female ones, at least in this series) and what people think to do with them can be repulsive. You can see some sample pages in Shaenon K. Garrity’s recommendation review.

The series certainly qualifies as horror, but I appreciated the mysteries and the sense of humor that enlivens the more gruesome events. And bless Dark Horse for including page numbers on almost every page, which comes in handy with the copious endnotes. Most of them reference the untranslated sound effects, including an essay on how kanji work, but some are fascinating cultural notes, or even odd little references to editor Carl Gustav Horn’s life or why Pac-Man is named that or mention of the lack of handguns in Japan. They’re the best translation notes in manga.

The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service Book 3 cover
The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery
Service Book 3
Buy this book

Volume two is a departure from the usual four chapters, four stories structure — it’s a single-volume story involving another unique business, a firm that promises to provide revenge to those who lost family members to murder, even after the killers have been executed. I’m impressed by how complex a tale develops from simple, expected elements: the team talking to a corpse as usual, Yata looking for a job that wants a Buddhist monk in training, a young girl with another death-related ability, Ao’s mysterious and tragic history, and an explanation for her fascination with bodies in the first place.

The longer story allows for more exploration of the personalities of the characters as they interact with each other and reveal their thoughts about what they do. It’s a real page-turner, with double crosses and more and more revelations as the story progresses. Plus, it helps bring into sharper relief the purpose of the Delivery Service.

This volume also has an afterword by the author where he explains part of his purpose in writing this series:

I thought it was odd how the walking dead had become such a normal sight in movies and video games — how much the idea of a zombie had been taken for granted. I wanted to get back to the fear any real person would feel, should death’s work appear to be unfinished.

Volume three opens with a protest against the U.S. war in Iraq, which leads the team to a black-market organ transplant operation whose “patients” are all suddenly dying. Kuro discovers that not only can corpses talk to him, but dead body parts as well, if they want to bad enough. (Just when you think this series can’t get any creepier, the author comes up with something like that!) The story winds up involving abuse of immigrants, soldiers’ bodies, and the scope of devastation caused by military action.

The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service Book 4 cover
The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery
Service Book 4
Buy this book

The next chapter features random attacks near a particular graffiti tag, that of an oni (demon). One of the victims needs the team’s assistance, but due to the violence of his beating, his body has amnesia. Even so, he ends up leading them to discover a kind of scavenger hunt of death. The final chapter has two mysterious happenings: an anonymous man who’s killed himself jumping in front of a train, and an ear found in a magazine at a used bookshop. How they connect is both coincidental and haunting.

In book four, the team, in need of money as usual, help a town create some crop circles. The burg is faking alien visitation to get more tourists, with a museum and UFO-themed snacks, and among their exhibits is a purported alien body. When the team encounter this particularly unusual corpse, they find that it only wants to go home. The country talk of their contact may seem stereotypical to some, making fun of rural attitudes, but I found it interesting that that type of character is apparently cross-cultural. And he was funny.

The next story returns to the more horrific approach typical of the series. An urban legend about a kidnapped, tortured student kept prisoner has unusual connections to a museum exhibition of plasticized bodies and, surprisingly, historical abuses. Kuro’s increasingly powerful abilities come through in a way that combines deus ex machina and his improving faith in himself. Sometimes it’s surprising how little the team does, other than showing up and making people nervous, but letting the dead take their own justice seems to be a theme of the series.

(It’s at this point that I note that we’ve now seen both the female team members naked, and there’s only been one instance of male nudity in the series, in a case with a serial killer early on. The male teammates stay fully clothed.)

The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service Book 5 cover
The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery
Service Book 5
Buy this book

The third story follows a dead baby left in a train locker, in which the team meets an unusual private investigator with a ghost for a client. There are hints of a bigger, continuing story involving Kuro’s companion ghost. The last story sends the team into nature to collect bugs, where they meet a visiting American exchange student crazy about insects (and who doesn’t wear much in the nature of shirts; she’s a stereotypical manga portrayal of the busty blonde foreigner) and of course find a body. Every time I think the series has gotten as creepy as it can, it manages to hit new heights, this time by featuring parasites.

The mood changes abruptly at the beginning of book five, as the team is entertaining at an old folks’ home. Yata’s puppet is a natural, telling jokes (and it’s so cute that when Yata puts on a tie, so does the puppet), but Makino’s bunny costume appears to have wandered in from another manga, and Numata as a clown shows why so many people find them scary. One of the inhabitants’ passing leads them to a ghost village with a legend of everyone being murdered.

Then there’s a mummy story, featuring the return of the company from the second book, who are now offering mummification as the latest status symbol. There’s always been something creepy about those monsters, with the viewer not knowing exactly what’s under the bandages, and it’s used to terrific effect here, with the additional comedy of students scraping for money resenting professors who are better off. Plus, some interesting information on how they were made.

In an attempt to find another way to earn funds, the group then announces themselves as professional mourners, hired to cry at funerals for people who don’t have anyone left to care for them. There are some weird callouts to otaku and bloggers, combined with an indictment of some ways to make money. That also plays a role in the last story, with a treasure hunt going on for a dead businessman’s missing fortune. The conclusion has some of the blackest, funniest humor in the series so far.

At the time of this writing, there are an additional four books:

With Book 10 due out this week. Publisher Dark Horse has posted previews of each book:

Also worth mentioning is the unique and appropriate design of the series, with “plain brown wrappers” livened with a neon-like highlight color, a dissected body diagram that has something to do with one of the interior stories, and images of some body part of the cast. First head shots, understandably, but then feet or necks, hands or eyes. It’s distinctive and eye-catching.

Similar Posts: Thought-Provoking LinkBlogging § Ghost Talker’s Daydream Books 1 and 2 § BPRD: Hollow Earth & Other Stories § What a Manga Ballot Should Look Like § Your and My Secret Book 1

Posted via email from skinnerbox’s posterous

CubeDude V.I.N.C.E.N.T.

Pretty cool Lego-inspired V.I.N.C.E.N.T. There seems to be a resurgence in interest in this character. Does anyone even remember Disney’s The Black Hole anymore? Apparently so…though I’d really like to forget that final sequence in the movie. It gave me nightmares for years.

Posted via web from skinnerbox’s posterous